Dr. Ray Andrew MD Explains how Rabbis have been misinformed,mislead,and deceived, into supporting Vaccination
March 22, 2019— Dr. Ray Andrew MD:
"I am running into increasing numbers of patients/parents who decline to receive vaccinations. I don’t call them “anti-vaxxers” because that is the most immature way I can imagine to refer to another human being with an opinion, whether I consider it informed or not. Name-calling is what people do in politics when they don’t have an intelligent response to an opposing party’s argument or viewpoint. This is supposed to be science, not politics.
"I am running into increasing numbers of patients/parents who decline to receive vaccinations. I don’t call them “anti-vaxxers” because that is the most immature way I can imagine to refer to another human being with an opinion, whether I consider it informed or not. Name-calling is what people do in politics when they don’t have an intelligent response to an opposing party’s argument or viewpoint. This is supposed to be science, not politics.
Based on my experience, those who choose not to vaccinate care just as
much about their children as you and I do. But they are looking for
information. They no longer consider the AAP and the CDC as unbiased
sources of information because the former has ties to the drug industry
and the latter actually owns vaccine patents. These parents want me to
show them long-term safety studies, which I am unable to find. They are
bothered by the ingredient lists of vaccines, knowing that there are
EPA-listed toxins in many of them. Some don’t like knowing that cells
and DNA from aborted fetuses as well as animals are used in vaccine
production. Some demand true double-blind, randomized,
placebo-controlled (using saline controls, not adjuvants) trials proving
efficacy, which simply do not exist, even though we keep telling
everyone that this is the gold standard in medicine. Some ask why—if
informed consent exists for every other procedure in medicine—doctors
and governments are trying to force vaccination on them, throwing
informed consent (a legal right, I was taught) out the window. Some make
the argument that, if vaccines are so effective, the vaccinated
shouldn’t worry about getting sick from the unvaccinated. And they ask
me for scientific proof of the theory of herd immunity. I don’t remember
being shown any evidence of this in medical school. It was simply
taught as a self-evident fact. But my patients don’t accept “facts”
anymore, not without seeing some proof.
So, when I receive all of these communications from different organizations telling me how I am supposed to combat the growing threat of vaccine deniers, I feel like a straw man because these communications never present actual evidence to respond to the questions of these parents. They’re just talking points, empty claims, and official pronouncements.
In conclusion, some of my patients vaccinate, and some don’t. I respect both kinds. They are both intelligent and care for their children. Last I checked, the Hippocratic oath doesn’t require me to insult people with whom I don’t agree. I present what evidence I can find, and let them choose based on their values, not mine. Maybe that’s not allowed anymore. Maybe I’m supposed to kick them out of my practice if they disagree with me. Maybe they should be kicked out of school. Out of the country, even. If that’s the America of the future, that’s not a country I would want to live in."
So, when I receive all of these communications from different organizations telling me how I am supposed to combat the growing threat of vaccine deniers, I feel like a straw man because these communications never present actual evidence to respond to the questions of these parents. They’re just talking points, empty claims, and official pronouncements.
In conclusion, some of my patients vaccinate, and some don’t. I respect both kinds. They are both intelligent and care for their children. Last I checked, the Hippocratic oath doesn’t require me to insult people with whom I don’t agree. I present what evidence I can find, and let them choose based on their values, not mine. Maybe that’s not allowed anymore. Maybe I’m supposed to kick them out of my practice if they disagree with me. Maybe they should be kicked out of school. Out of the country, even. If that’s the America of the future, that’s not a country I would want to live in."
Comments